Hi! For the new Square Online Store with Weebly there is an issue with the email contact form.
When a user submits an email through the contact form it lists Weebly as the reply-to instead of the user's email.
To reply back to the user you have to edit the "To" and delete out firstname.lastname@example.org. It's a small bug but pretty annoying because I always forget to change it each reply. It'll result in an error and having to resend it.
With an actual Weebly site, the contact form doesn't do this. It automatically has the user's email in the reply-to field. Attached is an example of what happens when you reply to a contact form.
The no-reply email is intentional so your email does not get blocked as Spoofing by email providers. When you send an email from your private domain address, but it's coming from Weebly - so Spam filters will reject this in many cases.
Happy to pass your feedback to the team about wanting it to come from your private domain, but the purpose is there to help drive deliverability.
@kellyj I just did a test and when I hit reply the To: field's email was filled with "email@example.com" which resulted in an error/bounce back. I think my inital post was a bit confusing.
If it helps, I am using Google apps for my domain's email. Here are screenshots:
After hitting "REPLY" to the test email, notice the sender's email? It shows their email as their name and their email address is firstname.lastname@example.org.
This is after I click on the TO: field, again, the email is noreply and the quoted part is their email when it should be their name.
Replied with a test response which sent back this error because the senders email was the noreply email. Hopefully, these photos help clear up the problem.